The Charming History of Pumpkin Carving (and How to Do It Beautifully)

There’s something magical about sitting down with a pumpkin, a knife, and a few friends as the evenings grow darker. Pumpkin carving has become one of the most beloved Halloween traditions — but it didn’t start with pumpkins at all.

Here’s a little of the history and a simple, elegant way to enjoy the tradition today.

A Brief History

Long before pumpkins were the star of the season, people in Ireland and Scotland carved faces into turnips and potatoes. They placed glowing coals inside to ward off spirits on All Hallows’ Eve. When Irish immigrants arrived in America, they discovered the native pumpkin was much larger and easier to carve — and a new tradition was born.

Choosing the Right Pumpkin

Look for a pumpkin with a flat bottom so it sits steadily, and one that still has a firm stem. Smaller pumpkins are often easier to work with and look charming on a porch or table.

Simple Carving Tips

  • Draw your design lightly with a pencil or marker first

  • Cut a lid around the stem at an angle so it doesn’t fall in

  • Scoop out the seeds and stringy pulp thoroughly

  • Start with a simple face — two eyes, a nose, and a smile still look wonderful when lit

Lighting Your Pumpkin

While battery-operated lights are safer and convenient, there’s nothing quite like the soft glow of a real candle flickering inside a freshly carved pumpkin and the scent that says Halloween from a freshly carved pumpkin.

A little candle trick: We’ve heard for years that putting candles in the refrigerator for a few hours - or overnight - before lighting them can help them burn more slowly. We do it every Halloween!

Did You Know?

Before pumpkins became the Halloween standard, people in Ireland traditionally carved turnips (and sometimes potatoes or beets) into lanterns called “Jack-o’-lanterns” to scare away wandering spirits.

Shop the Look

We’re gathering the Frightful and Bright finds we can’t stop thinking about! When the good stuff turns up, we’ll show you where to find it.

  • Classic carving kits with pattern templates

  • Battery-operated LED tea lights

  • Wood-handled pumpkin carving tools

  • Small decorative pumpkins for table displays

  • Black metal lanterns to hold mini pumpkins

Previous
Previous

Halloween Decorating Staples That Earn Their Keep

Next
Next

A 1920s Bogie Book Halloween Party, Reimagined